Located in Princeton, Milk & Cookies lovingly bakes the finest good, fresh cookies around.
Princeton folks need yummy, fresh-baked cookies and they need them now! They also need milk with their cookies, because, really, who doesn’t need milk with their cookies? And some folks are gluten free or vegan and they need cookies, too!
Milk & Cookies is a charming cookie shop based in Princeton, NJ. Every day, we bake good, fresh cookies and serve them along with nice, cold milk, and hot coffee and tea.
We also deliver to the famished folks in Princeton and Lawrenceville, as well as to lots of others in our area.
We offer gorgeous (and of course yummy!) cookie trays that are perfect for your next meeting, party, play, dance performance, recital, study break, symposium, etc. For more information, please click here.
Good Fresh Cookies - Single Cookie $3.25
Chocolate Chip
Crisp on the outside, chewy on the inside, full of melty chips. The platonic ideal of a chocolate chip cookie.
Chocolate Chunk
Crisp on the outside, chewy on the inside, full of big melty chips.
Toffee Cookies
Our own homemade toffee baked into a cookie. Possibly the yummiest cookie ever.
Snickerdoodles
A crispy sugar cookie with cinnamon sugar freckles
Heavenly Chocolate Cookie
Really it's that good.
Mexican Hot Chocolate
The yummy chocolate cookie with a real kick!
Double Chocolate
Rich chocolate cookies, warm chocolate chips. And did we happen to mention lots and lots of chocolate?
Peppermint Bark
A minty chocolate cookie with white chocolate chunks and crusted peppermint on top.
Sugar Cookie
Simple, elegant, delicious.
Confetti
Because it's New Year's Eve somewhere!
M&M Cookie
The cookie that thinks it's a party!
Ginger
Crunchy with a kick, if you like Pumpkin Spice, you'll LOVE our Ginger Cookies!
Lemon Poppy
Soft and chewy, lemony and poppy. Four good things in one.
Oatmeal Breakfast Cookie
Delicious and healthy. No added sugar, just some applesauce and honey.
Coffee Chip
Crisp on the outside, chewy on the inside. Full of melty chips, with a delicious coffee taste and topped with coffee icing.
Coffee Toffee
A Princeton favorite. A rich coffee cookie with huge chunks of our homemade toffee baked in.
London Foggy
Created in honor of London fog latte. These tea-licious cookies are a warm and cozy mix of black tea, vanilla and citrus.
Lavender
A crunchy touch of Spring!
Matcha Dreams
The big green monster with a white chocolate moon.
Pumpkin
If you like pumpkin spice, this is the cookie for you!
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip
Hearty and chocolaty.
Oatmeal Raisin
A classic cookie with a twist.
Gluten Free Chocolate Chip
Crisp on the outside, chewy on the inside, full of melty chips. The platonic icon of a chocolate chip cookie.
Rotating Gluten Free
Please call to see what we have today.
GF Oatmeal Chocolate Chip
Hearty and chocolaty.
GF Oatmeal Raisin
A classic cookie with a twist.
Vegan Chocolate Chip
All the fun of the classic, but vegan too!
Vegan Pumpkin
If you like pumpkin spice, this is the cookie for you!
Vegan Oat Chip
Enriched with lots of love, it's very, very yummy.
Cookie Assortments
Assortment of yummy cookies - Choose any of the flavors from our cookie list
$36
12 Cookies
$36
$72
24 Cookie Tray
$72
$120
40 Cookie Tray
$120
More than 100 cookies, please call for pricing
Mini Cookie Assortments
Assortment of cute mini cookies - Our mini flavors are currently Chocolate Chip, Heavenly Chocolate, Lavender, M&M, Snickerdoodle, London Foggy, Lemon Poppy, Confetti, Sugar, Ginger, Pumpkin, and Coffee Chip
$3.00
3 Mini Cookies
$3.00
$12
12 Mini Cookies
$12
$60
60 Mini Cookie Tray
$60
$90
90 Mini Cookie Tray
$90
More than 100 mini cookies, please call for pricing
Brownies
Ultra-fudge-y, incredibly delicious. Regular or Gluten Free. Choice of Plain, Monster, S’Mores, M&M, Blondie, and Happy Monkey.
$4.50
Big Brownie
$4.50
$1.25
Mini Brownie
$1.25
$25
Brownie Assortment
6 of our scrumptious brownies!
$25
$50
Brownie Tray
Brownies for a crowd!
$50
Nice Cold Milk
Milk Flavor Choice: Whole, 2%, Skim, Chocolate, Soy, Coconut
$2.75
Cup of Milk
$2.75
$7.50
1/2 Gallon of Milk
$7.50
$15.00
1 Gallon of Milk
$15.00
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Flavor Choice: Chocolate Chip - Chocolate, Chocolate Chip - Vanilla
$7.00
Large Ice Cream Sandwich
$7.00
$3.50
Mini Ice Cream Sandwich
$3.50
Cold Drinks
$3.75
Cold Brew
Icy cold, good and strong! Coffee Choice: Decaf, Regular
$3.75
$3.75
Iced Mocha
Bursting with coffee and chocolate!
$3.75
$2.75
Iced Tea
Perfect accompaniment for cookies. Iced Tea Choice: Darjeeling, Early Grey, Herbal Peppermint, Chai
$2.75
$2.75
Lemonade
Tart and sweet!
$2.75
Hot Drinks
$2.75
Coffee
Coffee Choice: Decaf, Regular
$2.75
$25.00
Coffee Box
Serves 15
$25.00
Tea
Tea Choice: Darjeeling, Earl Grey, Herbal Lemon, Herbal Peppermint, Japanese Sencha, Chai
$25.00
Tea Box
Your choice of Earl Grey, Darjeeling or Herbal Peppermint. Serves 15
$25.00